They home in on many of the same problems The Blaze pointed out.
And they basically come to the same conclusion: the tape is still a problem, but the impression it leaves is different.
Nearly all the videos used stitched-together, out-of-context remarks with no indication of what occurred or what was discussed just before and after the included portions.
Recorded sex chat videos
I think they employed both techniques in this.” reiterated assessments and warnings about O’Keefe’s methods in a 2011 piece targeting NPR.
That article noted that the time-consuming nature of fact-checking (particularly when source material is obscured) has led to Project Veritas efforts skating past cursory review: From where might we have learned such a lesson? Think ACORN and think Shirley Sherrod: job- and organization-crippling scandals in which the media blindly aided and abetted.
But they didn’t, so here we are with his NPR stunt, which allegedly shows NPR fundraiser Ron Schiller saying mean things about the Tea Party in a meeting with phony Muslim Brotherhood-connected donors. It’s not quite a Shirley Sherrod moment — where the right-wing video was edited to totally turn her message around — but it’s clear that things aren’t exactly what they first seemed.
But it appears that, once again, O’Keefe’s videos are not be what they seem. In one part of the video, NPR‘s Schiller seems to laugh about the phony Muslim group’s position on Sharia law. O’Keefe’s history should give media outlets serious reservations about taking him at face value on anything …
(And, yes, we at CJR should have been doing just as The Blaze did, searching for the discrepancies they found.) It’s telling because, as The Blaze showed, it takes time to vet a source.